John Wayne a Draft Dodger in World War II? The Argument Continues
"Here for the first time is the first hard evidence that [John] Wayne volunteered for potentially dangerous service with the equivalent of today's C.I.A., and the papers are not out of someone's attic, but official government documents."
That's the latest public defense of the World War II travails of John Wayne, courtesy of the politically conservative site Big Hollywood. The actor never quite made it into the Army or Navy, instead spending the war years making movies in Hollywood and doing USO tours. His fans say that John Wayne tried to join up but had a bad knee or a bad back, was deferred for family reasons, and so on. There are a number of possible excuses.
This latest defense is based on an application John Wayne apparently filed in 1943, hoping to get into Office of Strategic Services photo unit of director John Ford.
It's highly debatable whether getting into Ford's photo unit would equal "potentially dangerous service with the equivalent of today's C.I.A.," but let's just grant that it was. (Ford started out producing military documentaries and training films, and his units later followed the Allied advance across Europe, filming "installations, topography, and combat operations.")
This new argument, like so many others, still misses the point -- which is that even if he was rejected in this case (or others), John Wayne could still have patriotically signed up as an Army private at any time. He didn't.
In fact, the Big Hollywood article itself notes that point:
"By 1943, with officer's slots all filled, the only way Wayne could have gone into the service was as an army private; he had waited too long. Years later Wayne told Dan Ford that as a private, 'I felt it would be a waste of time to spend two years picking up cigarette butts. I thought I could do more for the war effort by staying in Hollywood.'"
"Two years picking up cigarette butts" is a pretty cold quote about the contributions of Army privates, isn't it? Would any Hollywood actor (or politician) today get away with describing Army service during the Iraq and Afghanistan wars as "two years picking up cigarette butts"?
Meanwhile, Clark Gable, at the time a far bigger star than Wayne (and at age 41, six years older) enlisted in the Army in 1942 and then went a step further and volunteered for combat duty. Gable also could have decided he would do more for the war effort by staying in sunny Hollywood, but he didn't.
The point isn't really to knock Wayne. I like many of his movies, especially those old beauties with Ford. And "draft dodger" isn't the right term anyway -- it's not like he fled the draft board and hid out.
The point that does matter to me is the historical one, which is that the loudest "patriots" and the strongest voices in favor of war are often people who avoided fighting one when they had the chance. Dick Cheney is only the latest example, with his infamous "I had other priorities in the '60s than military service" statement about joining up during Vietnam. We should be skeptical of those voices.
I think John Wayne's a good example of that idea. He later became a big supporter of the Vietnam War, even directing the film The Green Berets, in which a skeptical anti-war reporter is shown The Truth by Wayne's tough-guy Col. Kirby.
No doubt John Wayne did feel strongly about the Vietnam War. But by then, he was also safely past fighting age.
Lots of guys his age with bad knees and families made their way into the fighting in World War II, if they were determined enough. John Wayne could have too, and didn't. This latest document doesn't change that. In fact, it makes it all the clearer.